Shelter Island, NY > Shelter Island, NY

Heights Beauty

  • House
  • 4 Bedrooms
  • 7 Beds
  • 2 Bathrooms
  • 6 Guests
  • Pets Considered


Recharge your batteries at a picturesque historic retreat on Shelter Island. The spacious 1887 Carpenter Gothic feels like a luxury bed-and-breakfast with charm to spare. It’s close to Shelter Island restaurants and the Shelter Island Heights Beach Club, which offers a private beach, covered patios and cabanas, as well as access to two tennis courts.

The house welcomes guests from the moment they step onto the front porch with its gingerbread trim, porch swing and gorgeous hydrangea landscaping. Through the cathedral front door, the house opens to a front parlor sitting area. The main floor features an open kitchen, a dining area with a table that seats four, a comfortable living room with a fireplace and a screened porch from which to admire the scenic grounds. There is hardwood flooring throughout the house, which is decorated with style, elegance and an eye for the floral.

With four bedrooms, the house comfortably sleeps six guests. The bedrooms are tastefully decorated and balconies that offer beautiful views of the property.

*Pets are prohibited unless our express approval is provided 

Bedroom Configuration: 1 Queen, 1 Queen + 1 Twin Single, 3 Twin Singles, 1 Double
Bathroom Configuration: 2 Full, 1 Outdoor Shower

Read more


Sleeping arrangements

Bed Configuration

  • 1 Queen

Bed Configuration

  • 1 Queen
  • 1 Twin Single

Bed Configuration

  • 3 Twin Single

Bed Configuration

  • 1 Double/Full
Show all bedrooms

Bathroom arrangements

  • Full bath

  • Full bath

  • Outdoor shower
Show all bathrooms



  • Bed Linens
  • Bath Towels
  • Washer
  • Dryer
  • Air Conditioning
  • Hot Water
  • Usable Fireplace
  • Kitchen
  • Refrigerator
  • Living Room
  • Internet (Wifi)
  • Private Entrance
  • Carbon Monoxide Detector
  • Smoke Detector


  • Grill
  • Tennis Court


Suitability: Primary renter must be at least 30 years old.

Payment/Refund Policy: All payments are non-refundable, unless stated otherwise on the website you elect to book on. If you must cancel your reservation, we will re-list availability, and in the event we are able to re-book the nights you originally booked, a refund may be processed. We strongly encourage you to purchase travelers insurance (which we offer) as a means of payment protection. Please note that all bookings must be paid in full prior to arrival. Balance due payment methods will be determined by the size of the balance payment. Unfortunately, we cannot accept credit cards for payments over a certain value.


May 2020


We can notify you, if there is a price change.

0 Reviews


List Your Home

Let's Begin

Stay in the Know

Get the best deals and tips straight to your inbox.

Inquire Select Dates