Must-Try Lobster Rolls in the Hamptons
No trip to the Hamptons is complete without indulging in one of its most iconic culinary delights—the lobster roll. With its pristine waters and commitment to fresh, local ingredients, the Hamptons offers some of the best lobster rolls you can find. Whether you prefer your lobster warm and buttery or cold and seasoned, the Hamptons has a roll to satisfy every craving. Here's a guide to the top spots where you can savor the best lobster rolls in the Hamptons.
Duryea's Lobster Deck & Seafood Market
MontaukWhy You'll Love It: Duryea's has been a staple for over 85 years, offering breathtaking waterfront views alongside its celebrated lobster rolls. Their roll, featuring generous portions of lobster lightly dressed in mayo and celery, is a must-try. For a twist, sample their Lobster Cobb Salad. Prices are market-based.
The Lobster Roll (Lunch)
Amagansett and SouthamptonWhy You'll Love It: Known affectionately as "Lunch," this spot has been serving up classic lobster rolls since 1965. Choose between the Classic Lobster Salad Roll or the Hot Lobster Roll, each bursting with high-quality lobster meat. Enjoy your meal surrounded by nautical décor or in their retro diner setting.
Tillie's at Gurney's Resort
MontaukWhy You'll Love It: Tillie's offers a luxurious take on the Connecticut Hot Lobster Roll with a spicy sriracha mayo twist. Their Maine-style roll is equally delightful, served on buttery brioche. The ambiance of Gurney's resort adds to the experience, making it a perfect spot for a leisurely lunch.
Bostwick's Chowder House
East HamptonWhy You'll Love It: A local favorite, Bostwick's delivers with their Famous Lobster Salad Roll and Hot Buttered Lobster Roll. Served on a toasted potato bun, each roll is generously filled with lobster and complemented by their crispy fries. The cozy, seaside-themed restaurant makes every visit feel like a mini-vacation.
The Inlet Seafood Restaurant
MontaukWhy You'll Love It: Owned by local fishermen, The Inlet guarantees freshness. Larry's Lobster Roll, served on buttered brioche, combines cold lobster salad with a perfect blend of seasoning. Enjoy your roll with a side of coleslaw and hot fries while soaking in the waterfront views.
Clam Bar
MontaukWhy You'll Love It: This iconic clam shack offers both hot and cold lobster rolls that are a delight. The hot roll, packed with butter-poached lobster claw meat, and the cold roll, seasoned with just a touch of mayo, are both crowd-pleasers. The casual, roadside setting is perfect for a laid-back meal.
The Dock House
Sag HarborWhy You'll Love It: This family-run establishment serves up a simple yet exquisite lobster roll. Fresh lobster meat, lightly dressed and placed in a pillowy bun, is the star here. The Dock House's harbor views make it an idyllic spot for a casual meal.
Stuart's Seafood Market
AmagansettWhy You'll Love It: Stuart's has been a seafood haven since 1955. Their lobster rolls, filled with chunky lobster meat and a hearty amount of mayo, are served with coleslaw and kettle-cooked chips. The market atmosphere adds a charming touch to your visit.
The Seafood Shop
WainscottWhy You'll Love It: Don't let its modest exterior fool you—The Seafood Shop serves one of the best lobster rolls in the Hamptons. With a generous helping of lobster salad on a fresh potato bun, this spot offers incredible value and flavor. Enjoy your meal at their outdoor picnic tables.
As the sun warms the shores and summer takes hold, the allure of a perfect lobster roll becomes irresistible. Hearty chunks of succulent lobster meat, drizzled with melted butter or mixed with just the right amount of mayo and celery—each bite a taste of pure bliss. The Hamptons, with its fresh Atlantic lobsters, is the ideal place to enjoy this delicacy, rivaling even, dare we say, the famous rolls of Maine!