Avg. $1,322/night



Children Ages 2 - 12


  • House
  • 6 Bedrooms
  • 11 Beds
  • 6 Bathrooms
  • 10 Guests
  • Pets Not Permitted


Professionally manicured landscaping meets luxurious interior amenities. Spaciousness meets seclusion. And a relaxing Hamptons holiday meets a picture-perfect, high-end setting. There’s only one thing missing: You.

Shelter Island Manor—which sits on eight sprawling, private acres—consists of two separate dwellings, a heated pool, a two-car garage, and room for 6-8 parked cars in the large pebbled driveway. Both homes on the property are beautifully outfitted and comfortably furnished, making this the ideal place to relax and entertain all summer long.

In the 3-bedroom/2.5-bathroom main house, claim a space in front of the living room’s fireplace, or find a place to call your own in the plush family room, bright library, or quiet screened porch near the garden. Create a feast for the whole family in the eat-in kitchen, which features a sub-zero, Viking stove (with a second refrigerator in the butler’s pantry), two dishwashers, and two sinks. Then pass the plates and linger over a leisurely meal in the sun-soaked dining room — or move to the slate terrace, which has a table that comfortably accommodates eight.

The 3-bedroom/2.5-bathroom carriage house is also well equipped and ready to handle weekend guests or those who want a bit more space. Cook up breakfast in the kitchen, which has a refrigerator, dishwasher, and two-burner stove. On the second floor, find the property’s additional washer/dryer unit.

Shelter Island Manor’s gardens beckon for those who crave quiet time in nature, away from the city's chaos. The property’s heated pool is located in a very large enclosure, separate from the two dwellings and inviting for a morning swim. An outdoor shower keeps you sand-free after a day at the beach. Welcome to Shelter Island Manor.

*Please note that the carriage house will be unavailable until the end of March, as it is undergoing interior renovations 

*Pets are prohibited unless our express approval is provided

Bed Configuration: Main House: 1 King, 1 Queen, 2 Twin Singles, Guest House: 1 Queen, 2 Twin Singles, 4 Twin Singles

Bath Configuration: 4 Full, 2 Half, 1 Outdoor Shower

Read more


Sleeping arrangements

Bedroom 1 2nd Floor - Main House

Bed Configuration

  • 1 King


  • Air Conditioning
  • Ensuite Bathroom
    • Full
  • Television
    • Cable
  • Closet
    • Standard

Bedroom 2 2nd Floor - Main House

Bed Configuration

  • 1 Queen


  • Air Conditioning
  • Closet
    • Walk-in

Bedroom 3 Main House

Bed Configuration

  • 2 Twin Single


  • Air Conditioning

Bedroom 4 2nd Floor - Guest House

Bed Configuration

  • 1 Queen


  • Air Conditioning
  • Closet

Bedroom 5 2nd Floor - Guest House

Bed Configuration

  • 2 Twin Single


  • Air Conditioning

Bedroom 6 2nd Floor - Guest House

Bed Configuration

  • 4 Twin Single


  • Air Conditioning
Show all bedrooms

Bathroom arrangements

Bathroom 1 2nd Floor - Main House

  • Shower

Bathroom 2 2nd Floor - Main House

  • Shower

Bathroom 3 1st Floor - Main House

  • Half bath

Bathroom 4 2nd Floor - Guest House

  • Shower

Bathroom 5 2nd Floor - Guest House

  • Shower

Bathroom 6 1st Floor

  • Half bath

Outdoor Shower 1st Floor - Guest House

  • Outdoor shower
Show all bathrooms



  • Bed Linens
  • Bath Towels
  • Pool/Beach Towels
  • Hair Dryer
  • Iron/Ironing Board
  • Washer
  • Dryer
  • Air Conditioning
  • Heating
  • Hot Water
  • Usable Fireplace
  • Kitchen
  • Stove
  • Oven
  • Refrigerator
  • Ice Maker
  • Dishwasher
  • Microwave
  • Coffee
    • Pot
    • Nespresso
  • Toaster
  • Blender
  • Dishes and Silverware
  • Living Room
  • Internet (Wifi)
  • Cable TV
  • Smart TV
  • Speaker System
    • Sonos
  • Private Entrance
  • Parking
    • 4 Cars In Driveway
  • Garage
  • Carbon Monoxide Detector
  • Smoke Detector


  • Deck/Patio
  • Lounge Chairs
    • 4 Chairs
  • Patio Furniture
    • Table
    • Chairs
    • Umbrella
  • Grill
    • Gas
  • Outdoor Shower
    • Hot + Cold Water
  • Bicycle
    • 4 Adult Bikes
  • Beach Chairs
    • 6 Chairs
  • Beach Umbrella
  • Fence Around The Pool
  • Private Pool


Suitability: Not suitable for persons with disabilities.
Primary renter must be at least 30 years old.

Pet Policy: Pets are strictly prohibited at this property.

Utility Disclaimer:
Normal usage of the following utilities is included in the total booking amount:
Pool Heating (if applicable), Pool/Hot-Tub Maintenance (if applicable), Heating Oil/Propane/Natural Gas, Electricity, Cable/TV/Internet/Phone, and Garbage Removal

If the cost of utilities exceeds $130.00/night, guest will be responsible for the difference. Cleanings during a guest's stay and pay-per-view orders are not included in the cost of utilities.

Cleaning Disclaimer: All reservations longer than one week must be professionally cleaned once per week, the cost of which is borne by the guest. For clarity purposes, the cost of in-stay cleanings are separate and above the fees collected at the time of booking.

Additional Persons: No additional persons beyond the max occupancy of this listing are permitted.

Events Policy: Events are prohibited

Pool Disclaimer: Due to the climate of the northeastern U.S., outdoor pools and attached hot tubs will typically only be available for use from Memorial Day to Labor Day. If your booking falls outside of that time frame and you intend to use the pool/hot tub, please be sure to inquire if they will be available for use prior to booking.

Off-Season Disclaimer: It is typical that spring cleanings and updates do not take place until late April / early May. If your booking falls outside of Memorial Day to Labor Day, please inquire as to whether or not outdoor furniture and equipment will be available for use prior to booking.

Payment/Refund Policy: All payments are non-refundable, unless stated otherwise. If renter must cancel the reservation, Marquis will re-list availability, and in the event Marquis is able to re-book the nights renter originally booked, a refund may be processed. We strongly encourage renter to purchase travelers insurance (which Marquis offers) as a means of payment protection. Please note that all bookings must be paid in full prior to arrival.


January 2021


We can notify you, if there is a price change.

4 Reviews





Communication with Representative

Communication with Marquis

  • H. G.

    Heather G. 7 months ago

    I recently stayed at the property with my family and young children. We had an amazing stay at the property. The grounds were beautiful, pool amazing, and house clean. Great location to the beach. House had everything we needed. We were all so sad to go.

  • E. S.

    Ellen S. 2 years ago

    Wonderful experience - elegant, comfortable homes - easy to settle in! The pool was perfect for kid swim! Kim, the property manager was great! Hope to return for 4 days next June 27th!

  • R. A.

    Rosemarie A. 2 years ago

    We have had family reunions in California, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Spain and Portugal and this lovely estate on Shelter Island was by far the most comfortable and accommodating we have rented. The welcoming basket of gourmet goodies set the tone just as you walk into the kitchen and we knew immediately that this was a special place. And Kim, the manor\'s representative who met us, is a special person: gracious, kind and full of suggestions. The grounds are so secluded that we felt coddled. We loved the easy landscaping and the willowy grasses embracing the pool. We biked the lovely streets and byways (thanks to bikes on property), played badminton (we brought our own set) in the afternoon, cards and other games at night after supper, and even danced one evening. We barbecued vegetables for a pasta salad and baked cakes and lobster mac \'n\' cheese. We dined at Sunset Beach restaurant and watched the brilliant fiery sunset and had cocktails at Ram\'s Head Inn. We toured the ENTIRE island and walked the pebbly beaches (three of them!).. We greeted the deer and the turtle who visited and made friends with a black hen who thought she was an adopted member of the family. Every amenity is provided by the owner -- she must be a perpetual hostess for there was not a thing we needed or could have wanted. You really don\'t ever have to leave the grounds. Shelter Island Manor is the perfect retreat where sweet memories are made. RA

  • W. C.

    Wyatt C. 3 years ago

    Already want same place next year

Show all


List Your Home

Let's Begin

Stay in the Know

Get the best deals and tips straight to your inbox.


Avg. $1,322/night

Inquire Select Dates