Shelter Island Manor


5BR/6BA, comprised of a Main House + Charming Cottage Secluded Heated Pool

Shelter Island Manor


5BR/6BA, comprised of a Main House + Charming Cottage Secluded Heated Pool

Shelter Island Manor – a luxurious, secluded estate which sits on eight sprawling and very private acres. The property encompasses two separate dwellings, a heated pool, outdoor shower, two-car garage accessed by a wide pebbled drive which can accommodate parking for 6-8 cars.

Both homes on the property are professionally designed and decorated to be luxurious and welcoming, making this the ideal place to relax and entertain all summer long.

In the 3-bedroom/2.5-bathroom main house, claim a space in front of the living room’s fireplace, or find a place to call your own in the plush family room, private library, or serene screened porch near the garden. For even more privacy, escape to the master suite, with its own home office. Create a feast for the whole family in the large eat-in kitchen, which features a sub-zero, Viking stove (with a second refrigerator in the butler’s pantry), two dishwashers, and two sinks. Then pass the plates and linger over a leisurely meal in the sun-soaked dining room — or move to the slate terrace, which has a table that comfortably accommodates eight.

The 2-bedroom/2.5-bathroom  cottage is also professionally appointed and  equipped with its own office, perfect for guests who want a bit more private space. The cottage boasts its own kitchen, complete with refrigerator, dishwasher, and two-burner stove. On the second floor, find the property’s additional washer/dryer unit.

Shelter Island Manor’s gardens, with its large lawns and mature trees beckon for those who crave quiet time in nature, away from the city's chaos. A professional lighting system enhances the evening experience as does a professionally installed Sonos sound system with multiple zones inside and out.

The property’s heated pool is reminiscent of a pond, set in a very large, private enclosure with sea grasses and local shrubs. It is secluded and separate from the two dwellings, making it a perfect and very private spot for an early morning or midnight swim.

For those preferring the beach, there is a small and quiet beach a 5 minute walk from the house; an outdoor shower will be at the ready when you return.

This property has a max occupancy of 10


  • Bedroom 1 - Master: One King Bed, 2nd Floor, Air Conditioning, Full Ensuite Bathroom, Cable TV, Standard Closet
  • Bedroom 2: One Queen Bed, 2nd Floor, Air Conditioning, Walk-in Closet
  • Bedroom 3: Two Twin Single Beds, 2nd Floor, Air Conditioning
  • Bedroom 4 - Carriage House: One Queen Bed, Guest House 2nd Floor, Air Conditioning, Full Ensuite Bathroom, Closet
  • Bedroom 5 - Carriage House: One Queen Bed, Guest House 2nd Floor, Air Conditioning


  • Bathroom 1 - Master: Full Bath, 2nd Floor, Ensuite, Shower
  • Bathroom 2: Full Bath, 2nd Floor, Shower
  • Bathroom 3: Half Bath, First Floor/Main Floor, Handicap Accessible
  • Bathroom 4 - Carriage House: Full Bath, Guest House 2nd Floor, Ensuite, Shower
  • Bathroom 5 - Carriage House: Full Bath, Guest House 2nd Floor, Shower
  • Bathroom 6 - Carriage House: Half Bath, Guest House First Floor/Main Floor
  • Outdoor Shower: Outdoor Shower, Guest House First Floor/Main Floor


  • Bedroom 1 - Master: Cable

Outdoors & Pool/Spas
Bicycle (4 Adult Bikes), Grill (Gas), Deck/Patio, Lounge Chairs (4 Chairs), Patio Furniture (Table, Chairs, Umbrella), Outdoor Shower (Hot + Cold Water), Beach Chairs (6 Chairs), Beach Umbrella, Fence Around The Pool, Private Pool

Usable Fireplace, Air Conditioning, Dryer, Internet (Wifi), Washer, Garage, Hair Dryer, Living Room, Bath Towels, Bed Linens, Parking (4 Cars In Driveway), Private Entrance, Kitchen, Carbon Monoxide Detector, Smoke Detector, Hot Water, Refrigerator, Pool/Beach Towels, Iron/Ironing Board, Heating, Stove, Oven, Ice Maker, Dishwasher, Microwave, Coffee (Pot, Nespresso), Toaster, Blender, Dishes and Silverware, Cable TV, Smart TV, Speaker System (Sonos), Laptop-Friendly Workspace, Pots and Pans

Special Features
Set on 8 acres accessed by two private entrances. Completely secluded


Nearby Beaches:
5 minute walk to Bootlegger's Alley; 5 -5 minute bike ride to Crescent Beach.

Nearby Grocery Stores:
IGA in the Center; Marie Eiffel and STARS in the Heights.

Nearby Restaurants and Bars:
Isola - Heights
Ram's Head Inn - Big Ram Island
Salt - Montclair Colony

Many additional choices in Greenport and Sag Harbor

Other FAQ's

  • Pool Fenced In: Yes

Suitability: Not handicap accessible.
Primary renter must be at least 30 years old.

Pet Policy: Pets are strictly prohibited at this property.

Utility Disclaimer:
Utility fees are included in the total rental amount. The guest shall be responsible for the costs associated with excessive usage of utilities during the term of the reservation. Excessive usage is defined as utility costs over $130.00 per night of the reservation.

Cleaning Disclaimer: One end of stay cleaning is included in the reservation total. For reservations longer than seven nights, one cleaning per week is mandatory. In-stay cleanings are the guest's expense.

Additional Persons: No additional persons beyond the max occupancy of this listing are permitted.

Events Policy: Events are prohibited

Pool Disclaimer: Due to the climate of the northeastern U.S., outdoor pools and attached hot tubs will typically only be available for use from Memorial Day to Labor Day. If your booking falls outside of that time frame and you intend to use the pool/hot tub, please be sure to inquire if they will be available for use prior to booking.

Off-Season Disclaimer: It is typical that spring cleanings and updates do not take place until late April / early May. If your booking falls outside of Memorial Day to Labor Day, please inquire as to whether or not outdoor furniture and equipment will be available for use prior to booking.

Payment/Refund Policy: Unless otherwise stated on the property listing, all payments are non-refundable, however, should the guest elect to cancel its reservation, Marquis will use best efforts to work with the owner of the property to reopen the dates of the reservation in attempt to re-book the property (please note the decision to reopen dates is the owners'). Should Marquis be successful in re-booking the property for the original dates at the same or higher price than the original reservation, a refund less a 20% penalty, calculated as 20% on the total reservation amount, will be issued to the guest once payment is collected in full for the new reservation. If a new reservation is not made, the guest may use the property for the dates of its original reservation so long as payments have been made in accordance with the payment schedule established at the time of booking and Marquis is notified in writing 72 hours or more prior to the start of the reservation.

Security Deposit Disclaimer: Although rare, accidental damage does happen during a stay. In lieu of a security deposit, guests can rest easy knowing that this property is covered with up to $20,000 of "all risk" damage protection provided by Waivo. Coverage details are provided in the booking agreement.

While StayMarquis manages this listing, the guest experience is managed by the owner of this property, meaning all property preparation, arrival coordination, in-stay communication, and requests for maintenance tasks are performed by the owner. However, StayMarquis will provide you with a "Guest Experience Manager" who can help facilitate any request, from grocery shopping to organizing a private chef.