(12)
Book a Property (12)
5
6
10
Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island Manor
Avg. $1,599/night
5
6.0
10
Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island Manor
Avg. $1,599/night
4
3
8
Shelter Island, NY
Ram Island Drive
Avg. $1,260/night
4
3.0
8
Shelter Island, NY
Ram Island Drive
Avg. $1,260/night
4
3
6
Shelter Island, NY
Joyful on Shelter Island
Avg. $883/night
4
3.0
6
Shelter Island, NY
Joyful on Shelter Island
Avg. $883/night
4
2
6
Shelter Island, NY
East Brander Escape
Avg. $627/night
4
2.0
6
Shelter Island, NY
East Brander Escape
Avg. $627/night
3
3
8
Shelter Island, NY
Boathouse
Avg. $1,928/night
3
3.0
8
Shelter Island, NY
Boathouse
Avg. $1,928/night
4
2.5
8
Shelter Island, NY
The Shelter Island Farmho...
Avg. $1,088/night
4
2.5
8
Shelter Island, NY
The Shelter Island Farmhouse
Avg. $1,088/night
6
5.5
12
Shelter Island, NY
Sunset Beach
Avg. $4,710/night
6
5.5
12
Shelter Island, NY
Sunset Beach
Avg. $4,710/night
5
4.5
9
Shelter Island, NY
Water Haven
Inquire for rates
5
4.5
9
Shelter Island, NY
Water Haven
Inquire for rates
5
4
10
Shelter Island, NY
Great Circle Serenity
Inquire for rates
5
4.0
10
Shelter Island, NY
Great Circle Serenity
Inquire for rates
7
5.5
14
Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island Escape
Inquire for rates
7
5.5
14
Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island Escape
Inquire for rates
3
2
6
Shelter Island, NY
Cozy Lane
Inquire for rates
3
2.0
6
Shelter Island, NY
Cozy Lane
Inquire for rates
3
2.5
5
Shelter Island, NY
West Neck Contemporary
Inquire for rates
3
2.5
5
Shelter Island, NY
West Neck Contemporary
Inquire for rates
List Your Home
Let's Begin